20 Old-Fashioned Pie Recipes To Make This Weekend — Eat This Not That

20 Old-Fashioned Pie Recipes To Make This Weekend — Eat This Not That

Sure, trendy pastries and cookies with cult followings are delicious, but sometimes, it’s nice to indulge in some old-school desserts. The next time you want to bake a pie, why not go for an old-fashioned one? After all, nothing hits the spot quite like a classic apple, banana cream, or chess pie.

If you’re looking to take a trip back in time with your next baking endeavor, then look no further. From chocolate pudding pie recipes that achieve the perfect balance of taste and texture to pecan pies that taste just like grandma’s, you’ll be sure to find the perfect vintage pie to make this weekend from the following list. And next, don’t miss these 20 Old-Fashioned Midwestern Dessert Recipes.

Coconut Cream Pie
Courtesy of Lil’ Luna

You only need a handful of ingredients to whip up this luscious coconut cream pie: milk, eggs, shredded coconut, and whipped cream. Enjoy a slice plain or top it with fresh berries for an even tastier treat.

Get the recipe from Lil’ Luna.

Chocolate Cream Pie
Courtesy of Half Baked Harvest

Get transported back to childhood with this easy-to-make chocolate cream pie. Packed with dark chocolate, vanilla, and hazelnut flavors, this delicious dessert requires just 20 minutes of prep time.

Get the recipe from Half Baked Harvest.

Buttermilk Pie
Courtesy of Lil’ Luna

This scrumptious buttermilk pie, which takes just five minutes to throw together, tastes exactly like grandma’s recipe. The best part? It can be stored in the freezer in a freezer-safe Ziploc bag for up to two months.

Get the recipe from Lil’ Luna.

Damson Plum Pie
Courtesy of The Seasoned Mom

Juicy plums are put to good use in this damson plum pie. Made using damson plum preserves, brown sugar, and vanilla extract, this unique treat tastes even more delicious when paired with vanilla bean ice cream and a drizzle of caramel sauce.

Get the recipe from The Seasoned Mom.

RELATED: The Best Pie in Every State

Vintage Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Courtesy of Half Baked Harvest

If you’re a big fan of Reese’s peanut butter cups, then you have to give this vintage chocolate peanut butter pie a try. Featuring dark chocolate, salted pretzels, cream cheese, and fluffy whipped cream, this simple recipe may just become a go-to for peanut butter lovers.

Get the recipe from Half Baked Harvest.

Strawberry Sponge Pie
Courtesy of Flour on my Face

Freshly picked strawberries make a welcome appearance in this old-fashioned sponge pie recipe, which comes from a vintage cookbook.

Get the recipe from Flour On My Face.

Chocolate Pudding Pie
Courtesy of The Seasoned Mom

Is there anything more delicious than chocolate pudding pie? Made with Jello chocolate pudding mix, unsweetened baking chocolate, and a graham cracker crust, this delectable dessert can be put together in an impressive 15 minutes.

Get the recipe from The Seasoned Mom.

blueberry pie
Courtesy of Inspired Taste

Wow your family and friends by whipping up a homemade blueberry pie—we promise you it’s easier than it seems. All you need are a handful of ingredients, including blueberries, lemon zest, and allspice.

Get the recipe from Inspired Taste.

French Silk Pie
Courtesy of Sally’s Baking Addiction

French silk pie is the perfect combination of light chocolate mousse, flaky pie crust, and airy whipped cream. Make sure to garnish with shaved dark chocolate for the full effect.

Get the recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

RELATED: The Best & Worst Pies—Ranked by Nutritional Benefits!

Million Dollar Pie
Courtesy of Flour on my Face

This million-dollar pie recipe, which is made with crushed pineapple, whipped toppings, and a graham cracker crust, dates all the way back to the 1940s. One of the best things about this rendition is that it requires no baking and can be put together in a quick 10 minutes.

Get the recipe from Flour On My Face.

Lemon Cream Pie
Courtesy of Well Plated

This creamy, mouthwatering lemon pie is sure to be a crowd pleaser at your next get-together. It tastes just like grandmas!

Get the recipe from Well Plated.

Chess Pie
Courtesy of Cooking Class

Move over, apple and pumpkin pie—there’s a new favorite pie in town. This chess pie recipe, which calls for cornmeal, salted butter, and vanilla extract, will have you rethinking your summer holiday pie menu.

Get the recipe from Cooking Classy.

Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie
Courtesy of Sally’s Baking Addiction

Nothing hits the spot quite like a piece of good old sweet potato pie. This variation is made using smooth bourbon and marshmallow topping.

Get the recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

lemon meringue pie
Shutterstock

No kitchen is complete without a perfect lemon meringue pie recipe on hand. Teeming with both texture and flavor, this tasty vegan dessert takes just 15 minutes to make.

Get the recipe from A Big Man’s World.

Pecan Pie
Courtesy of Sally’s Baking Addiction

Pecan pie has been satisfying even the pickiest of palates for years. This recipe, which features chopped pecans, flaky pie crust, and ground cinnamon, is perfect for holiday dinners, summer barbecues, birthday parties, and more.

Get the recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

RELATED: The Best Healthy Pecan Pie That Will Impress Your Guests

Apple Pie
Courtesy of Inspired Taste

You can’t go wrong with apple pie. Made using four pounds of baking apples, ground ginger, and nutmeg all stuffed into a flaky pie crust, this pie is sure to be a showstopper.

Get the recipe from Inspired Taste.

Banana Cream Pie
Courtesy of Ambitious Kitchen

Banana cream pie is one of those desserts that checks all the boxes. Not only is it scrumptious, but it’s also the perfect balance between both flavor and texture. This version is made using a peanut butter cookie crust, so you know it’s going to be good!

Get the recipe from Ambitious Kitchen.

tomato pie
Courtesy of How Sweet Eats

This unexpected yet delicious pie helps put leftover produce to good use. Featuring juicy tomatoes, bread crumbs, parmesan, and more, one slice will have you looking for seconds. One of its best parts is its flaky cheddar crust, which is made with grated sharp cheddar cheese and a medley of aromatic spices.

Get the recipe from How Sweet Eats.

Apple Crumble Pie
Courtesy of Averie Cooks

If you can’t decide if you want to bake an apple pie or an apple crumb, then why not make both? This apple crumble pie, which is made using canned apple pie filling and caramel sauce, is a clear winner.

Get the recipe from Averie Cooks.

pear pie
Courtesy of Kim Cravings

You may be familiar with apple pie, but have you ever given pear pie a try? This old-fashioned pear pie recipe calls for freshly chopped pears, lemon zest, cinnamon, and fresh ginger. Hint: use Bartlett pears for their crispy texture and undeniable flavor.

Get the recipe from Kim’s Cravings.

For more awesome dessert ideas, check out 14 Healthy, Guilt-Free Cake Recipes That Are Perfect for Weight Loss

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.